top of page
  • Writer's pictureDr. Margot Rejskind

First-World Choir Problems

Last fall, I started a new men’s choir. Our initial recruitment was what I like to call the “Y’All Come” approach: we made it clear that we welcomed any man who wanted to sing*; as a result, we started with 8 men of extremely varied levels of experience. We had a couple of university music students, several men who have sung with choirs for years, one with only a little choral experience, and one with none at all.

As you might expect, we did not get as neat a balance of voices as one might wish. Which is to say that we are baritone-heavy  (surprise!), and that both the bass and second tenor sections are currently one-man shows. But the good news is that in spite of this, the balance is really very good – better than good, actually. I am the happy director of a small group of men who sing with dead-on intonation, and remarkable ensemble. We get warm, ringing chords even in the initial stages of learning music, and when I ask them to sing something a certain way, they do – and they do it again the following week. These guys are already, in many ways, a dream ensemble.

Now, there are a lot of reasons for that, I’m sure. Right from the first rehearsal, we spent time building the ensemble sound, working on listening skills, and singing technique. But we also had a great sound right from the first rehearsal, so obviously some of that is the particular mix of voices.

It’s clear that we need at least a few more singers – if only so my second tenor can breathe once in awhile. But it’s also clear that I need to give careful consideration to how I am going to continue taking men into the choir. As I see it, I have three options:

1. Remain unauditioned, and rely on hard work and ensemble skills to integrate all newcomers. 2. Move to an auditioned system. 3. Find the middle ground – maybe a probation period for new members, to see how they integrate.

All of these have both advantages and disadvantages; option 1, for example, might mean more singers, but also more work, and could set us up to have to deal with a voice that doesn’t suit our group. Likewise, auditioning would likely keep some perfectly good singers from coming to us, and a probationary period would inevitably cause some hard feelings when we had to tell someone that they can’t stay. In a small province, those kinds of hard feelings have larger repercussions than they might elsewhere.

So, I have some cogitating to do.


*I did make the conscious choice not to invite women who sing in traditionally male ranges, not because I disapprove – I don’t – but as a matter of aesthetic, which bears discussing some other time.

7 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Dealing With The Haters

If you're going to spend your professional life getting up in front of groups of people and telling them what to do and how to do it, sometimes - maybe always - some of those people are not gonna like

The moment that makes it all worthwhile

I think everyone seeks validation in life, as a matter of course. We all want to feel like we matter, like we can achieve something positive. Choral conducting is a long game. It’s a reality of the jo

Making peace with imperfection

I have never ever had a perfect performance. I’ve done some great, even remarkable concerts, but the truth is that something always goes sideways in a performance. I often tell my choirs that live per


bottom of page