Search
  • Dr. Margot Rejskind

The Freedom To Breathe

I’ve been thinking a lot lately about breathing as it relates to the choral singer. As a singer and voice teacher myself, I obviously take the connection of air to sound very seriously. And certainly, increasing the physical integration of the breath in one’s singers is a priority for every choral director. To be honest, I could write a book on breathing in the choral context, and maybe one day I will. But what I’ve been reflecting upon lately is my approach to corporate breathing – how and when we breathe as an ensemble.


I was, as I believe many conductors are, raised to insist that singers breathe only where I want them to breath, musically. As a choral singer, I was called out for taking a breath where none was indicated, and I considered that to be appropriate – I should not have needed a breath there.


As a director, this regularly raised questions from my choirs – “Margot, where should we breathe in this phrase?” Often, I was asking for some very long phrases, and while I was always willing to spend time working on how to breathe through those long phrases, in practice I very often ended up having to rework the phrasing, or just put up with singers snatching breaths here and there.


Then a couple of years ago, I had a week of revelation. My barbershop chorus was in a coaching with a respected coach, who told them that they should feel free to breathe up to 30% of the time, so that they would only be singing for 70% of the piece. This seemed a little extreme to me (actually, it still kind of does), but it did put different spin on things: at the end of that session, the chorus had a more unified, consistent sound, and I couldn’t argue with that. Then later that week, I read a comment from the great Tim Seelig, “no singer should ever take a breath because they need one”. And the lightbulb finally went on above my head.


If an amateur singer is taking a breath because they feel they need it, then it is most likely that their tone has already suffered for lack of support. Multiply that by 45 people in a choir, that’s a lot of choral tone we’re leaving on the table! Obviously, I was going to need to pay some attention to our breathing practice.


Over time, I’ve come up with three discrete approaches to ensemble breathing, each of which is useful in a specific type of situation. There is, of course, the staggered (or, more elegantly, dovetailed) breath, where singers breathe individually throughout the phrase. It’s worth noting that this is a complex approach which requires rehearsal, both in and out of context. I say this because in 25 years of singing in choirs, I never once had a director even really explain “staggered breathing”, let alone practice the technique (“just stagger through there” is what we mostly heard – and stagger we did).


There’s what I call PCBs (Personal Choice Breaths), wherein singers breathe individually as needed, even if they have regular breaths called for in the music. Although I would like them to be able to sing through a long phrase without needing to stop for air, the fact is that I don’t feel so strongly as to be willing to sacrifice our sound to achieve it.


Finally, sometimes I still insist on singing through a phrase. When I do this, I know that I may need to spend time rehearsing not only the phrase, but also the breaths leading into and out of it. But it’s worth taking the time, given the results – better ensemble, better tone, better intonation, better musicality. Because as it turns out, the breaths are part of the music, too.

1 view

Recent Posts

See All

Dealing With The Haters

If you're going to spend your professional life getting up in front of groups of people and telling them what to do and how to do it, sometimes - maybe always - some of those people are not gonna like

Making peace with imperfection

I have never ever had a perfect performance. I’ve done some great, even remarkable concerts, but the truth is that something always goes sideways in a performance. I often tell my choirs that live per

© 2019 by Margot Rejskind